Here in Louisville.
Local pickup and delivery begin on the same official order menu.
Order local cookiesVisit door 106BPenny & Pearl’s / St. Matthews, Louisville
Made on Fairfax.
Headed your way.
From the finishing touch to the cookie box. Order local, or send a dozen across the country.
Order pickup or delivery(502) 890-6004
Cookie craft, close up.The making
Finish it.
Box it.
Make someone’s day.
A torch, a tray, a finishing touch. Real cookies, made in the bakery on Fairfax.
Go big on the occasion
Make it
a cookie cake.
Birthdays, parties, celebrations, or just because. Start with the bakery’s cookie-cake menu.
Order a cookie cakeThe destination
Here?
Or there?
Home kitchen, 2020. Fairfax, 2021.
Made here.
Grown here.
Penny & Pearl’s began in March 2020 in the home kitchen of Natalie and Amanda Zant. In 2021, with the Louisville community’s support, the bakery opened its St. Matthews storefront.
Today, the focus is still fresh-baked cookies and a warm welcome on Fairfax.
Visit the St. Matthews bakeryFrom the cookie counter · September 29–October 3, 2026
Seasonal flavors.
Something to come back for.
This past lineup included pumpkin oatmeal chocolate chip, peanut butter cup, Krispie rice bars and the bakery’s cookie favorites.
Flavors change. Check the official menu for current choices and availability.
Check the current local menu