Penny & Pearl’s · St. Matthews
A little Fairfax.
A lot of cookie.
Fresh-baked cookies for your Louisville day—or a dozen for someone miles away.
(502) 890-6004
Get to know the dozens
Six good places
to start.
A single flavor, a sandwich cookie, or the bakery’s own assortment. Meet the shipping collection.
Home kitchen → St. Matthews
A bakery with
a Fairfax home.
Penny & Pearl’s began in March 2020 in the home kitchen of Natalie and Amanda Zant. In 2021, with the Louisville community’s support, the bakery opened its St. Matthews storefront.
Today, the focus is still fresh-baked cookies and a warm welcome on Fairfax.
Find us on Fairfax
Bring something to the party
The cookie.
The whole occasion.
Birthdays, parties, celebrations, or just because. Find cookie cakes on the bakery’s local order menu.
Order a cookie cakeChoose your options and confirm availability with the bakery.
From the cookie counter · September 29–October 3, 2026
Seasonal flavors.
Something to come back for.
This past lineup included pumpkin oatmeal chocolate chip, peanut butter cup, Krispie rice bars and the bakery’s cookie favorites.
Flavors change. Check the official menu for current choices and availability.
Check the current local menu
Make a stop
at the counter.
106 Fairfax Avenue, Louisville.
Look for the mint storefront and door 106B.